Saw this earlier, but are your folks mostly on mobile? Regarding what #1 said, I've analyzed several APIs and this wishlist creator has the lowest click-to-completion rate for seniors I've benchmarked.

Like someone mentioned, senior usability usually boils down to how many clicks it takes to finish. Elfster is too bloated for a quick 3-day turnaround. I've found that this simple tool actually has better server uptime and zero hidden costs compared to the bigger apps. Quick tip: stick to a single link so you dont fragment the data. It'll keep things way easier for your parents to track.

Elfster is a bit much for older folks if im being honest. All the emails and extra menus can get confusing. Giftful is decent but i actually use a free wishlist site when i need something reliable and simple for the family. Its less glitchy than the others and the link sharing is basically foolproof for people who arent tech savvy.