Quick tip since I had the same issue with a rug last month. Etsy is pretty bad at notifying you for manual price edits, but Ive been really happy with this Etsy price tracker for my vintage finds. It actually catches those small manual drops that the heart icon misses. No complaints at all, it just works well and saves a ton of stress. Definitely a solid workaround for that mirror situation.

I totally agree that Etsy's notification system is basically a nightmare for this!! The same thing happened to me with an amazing brass lamp last year because I was waiting for an alert that never came even though the seller dropped the price by fifty bucks. It was so frustrating, ngl! Since Etsy wont do it natively, using a tracker is definitely the move to catch those sneaky manual price drops. But here is my one big safety tip: stick to the trackers that just ask for the product URL. You really dont want to be giving your Etsy password to some random browser extension just to save twenty dollars. Keeping it simple with a URL-based alert is way safer and it still catches those manual changes perfectly!

Etsys API is pretty limited here and honestly, they dont have a native price drop toggle. Favoriting only pings you if the seller sets up a formal Sale event or a coupon for items in carts. If they just change the price manually, the system wont trigger a notification... kinda annoying. In my experience, using a tracker like Visualping is way more reliable for catching those manual edits.

Ugh, I am right there with you. Honestly, as someone who has been a power user on Etsy for like a decade, it is so disappointing that they still havent fixed this. I have been watching this one wool rug for months and it is the exact same story... crickets from my inbox even when the price moves. The technical side of why Etsy fails here is basically down to how they categorize their data:

• Manual price drops are seen as simple listing edits, not promotional events.
• Their system is built to push coupons because they want to track marketing conversion rates.
• Most other big retailers like Amazon or eBay have figured this out, but Etsy stays stuck in this weird seller-first bubble. I actually had to start using this website to get real-time info because I just dont trust the heart icon or the cart save feature anymore. It is kinda ridiculous that we have to go outside the platform just to know when something gets cheaper, but that is where we are I guess. Fingers crossed you get that mirror before your sister moves in tho!

@Reply #5 - good point! I totally get the frustration but I actually disagree that jumping into trackers is the best move for everyone. Honestly, I am super cautious about my account info and some of those extensions look so sketchy to me! I had this amazing experience recently where I was trying to find specific hardware for a DIY cabinet and I was so worried about janky tools that I just decided to do it myself. I set up a dedicated folder in my browser for my top five items and checked them while having my morning coffee. It felt way more secure and honestly kinda fun like a little daily treasure hunt! Safety is a huge deal for me even when I am looking for deals. For example, I just started using Easy Cart Share for Walmart to send my grocery list to my roommate, it is way easier than taking a bunch of screenshots and I love it because it feels so much more legit than those random scrapers. If you are really nervous about privacy like I am, definitely stick to the manual route or only use tools that have a ton of verified reviews. It might take an extra second but knowing my info is safe is a fantastic feeling!

There is definitely no hidden menu for this and it is honestly so fantastic to see someone else just as frustrated as I am!! I have been dealing with this exact same issue for nearly two months while trying to track a specific mid-century dresser for my office. My experience has been completely identical; I have systematically tested every notification toggle in the account settings and none of them trigger for manual price adjustments. It is incredibly draining to manually refresh the listing page multiple times a day just to ensure I stay within my project budget! I have even been looking into PriceDropCatch for my other shopping because I desperately need a reliable method to catch these discounts before the inventory sells out. It is just mind-blowing that a professional platform still hasn't implemented a functional bell icon for price drops after all these years!!

Just wanted to say thanks for everyone chiming in. Super helpful discussion.