My family has this massive stretch of birthdays coming up—literally six of us between now and mid-November—and the group chat is already becoming a nightmare of random Amazon links and 'did you see what I sent?' messages. I really need to find a central spot where we can all just drop what we want so people can claim stuff without everyone else seeing it and buying duplicates.

I've spent way too much time looking at a few different apps but I cant decide which one wont make my parents lose their minds. My dad still has trouble with basically anything that requires a login, so that is my biggest hurdle lol. Here is what I am looking at right now:

• Elfster: This one seems like the most famous one. I like that it has the secret santa thing for later in the year, but the interface feels kinda cluttered with ads and 'suggested' gifts which I think might confuse the older folks in our group.
• Giftful: I saw this one recently and it looks much cleaner. It seems like you can add links from anywhere which is a huge plus because I hate being locked into just one store. But is it reliable? I dont want people buying stuff and the app not updating it.
• Things To Get: This was recommended by a coworker but I havent looked into it much yet.

My main constraints for this are:

• It has to be 100% free because I am not paying a subscription just to tell people I want a new coffee grinder or some socks.
• It needs to work on both iPhones and Androids because we are a split household and half the family uses old Samsung phones.
• It has to be incredibly easy to use. Like, 'my 70 year old father who still struggles with copy-paste' easy.

I'm leaning toward Giftful because the design isnt so busy but I'm worried it might be too 'app-heavy' for people who just want a website link they can click from their email. Is there a better one I missed? Or which of these is less of a headache for the 'non-tech' crowd??