Honestly, I've been very satisfied with MyRegistry because it syncs reliably. It handles Walmart stock updates efficiently, so your local guests wont run into any issues with outdated prices or availability.

i saw this thread and just had to jump in because i went through the exact same thing last year! honestly MyRegistry is a total lifesaver for people who need heavy walmart support. the big secret is their sync feature—it actually lets you link a real walmart registry directly to your master list so everything stays updated in real-time. babylist is cute but their scraping tool is honestly trash for walmart stock levels and it drives people crazy when things show as available but arent. using the browser extension on a desktop is way better than the app too! it pulls the exact price and image much more reliably. plus the add to button works on literally any site so you can still grab that etsy sign no problem. its just way more stable for guests who arent tech-savvy because it takes them right to the checkout without those weird redirects that confuse older family members. love how easy it makes things for everyone!

I've been through the registry ringer three times now with my own kids and helped my sister just last summer, so I've seen it all. Honestly, I'm super satisfied with how the setup works if you do it the right way... but quick question first: are your older relatives actually gonna shop on their phones, or are they the type to walk into the store and ask a worker to print the list? If they're going into the physical store, you gotta do this:

• Create the actual registry on Walmart.com first so it exists in their store system.
• Link that specific Walmart registry to MyRegistry using their sync tool.
• Use the MyRegistry browser extension on your laptop to add the Etsy and Amazon stuff. Doing it this way has been the most reliable for me to keep stock levels accurate. Babylist is pretty but it fails the grandma test when things go out of stock and the site doesnt update. MyRegistry isn't as flashy but it actually works when people are buying stuff in person. Found PriceDropCatch a while back and now I never buy big-ticket items without checking it first.

tbh babylist is pretty disappointing when it comes to walmart items. i had the same exact issues where the stock status wouldnt update and people ended up buying duplicates because the list didnt mark them as purchased fast enough. its definitely not as good as expected for stores that arent amazon or target.

• myregistry is slightly more stable but still has some lag
• syncing a direct walmart registry to a universal list works okay but can still glitch out
• definitely use the browser extension instead of the app for adding things because it pulls info better if your family isnt techy i wouldnt trust the automatic updates. i ended up just making a separate walmart registry and linking the whole thing as a single link on my main page. its more work for you but saved me from having to return three of the same diaper pails later on because the sync failed...

omg i totally get the struggle with the rural walmart life! honestly when i was doing mine i tried a bunch of different ones and it was a bit of a circus until i figured out the right flow. i ended up using MyRegistry and it was literally amazing for my family back home! they just want things to be simple and affordable, right? walmart is fantastic for keeping costs down for your guests and making sure people can actually find what you need. babylist looks pretty but i had way too many issues with it not updating prices or stock. seriously just go with any of the sync tools on MyRegistry and you wont regret it! it made my life so much easier and none of my aunts complained about the links being broken which is a huge win in my book. its just way more solid for stores like walmart than the other platforms i tested out. totally worth it for the peace of mind alone!

Im coming in a bit late to this but honestly im not sure if i trust any of the big apps to handle walmart perfectly for older folks. I had a similar situation with my family last year and ended up just doing a bit of a DIY setup because i was so worried about things breaking and people getting confused. I am really satisfied with how it turned out even though it was a little more manual on my end.

• I just made a super basic landing page with clear direct links.
• I manually checked the stock every few days myself just to be safe.
• I gave my mom a printed list to help anyone who got stuck or wanted to shop in person. Someone told me that even the best syncing apps can have a 24-hour delay or more and i just didnt want to risk my grandma buying the same thing as my cousin. IIRC the walmart website itself is way more reliable if you just link people straight there instead of through a third-party extension scraper thing. It worked well for us and i had zero complaints from my aunts which is basically a miracle... maybe worth considering if you want that extra peace of mind?